Nebraska Wesleyan University ranks among the all-time leaders in the entire nation, regardless of college division (NCAA Division I, II, III and NAIA), with 80 student-athletes, who have won 119 CoSIDA Academic All-American awards between them.
The total ranks NWU 10th among all schools. NWU ranks fourth among NCAA Division III institutions. Nebraska Wesleyan holds nearly 100 more Academic All-America awards than its nearest competitor within the GPAC.
Nebraska Wesleyan has produced nine CoSIDA Academic All-Americans during the 2011-12 school year with seven football players earning Academic All-American honors, as well as one men's basketball player and one women's basketball player. Four football players were First-Team Academic All-Americans to lead all schools in the country in the college division.
Since 2000, NWU has produced 56 CoSIDA Academic All-Americans, which also ranks in the top 15 in the nation.
To be eligible for CoSIDA Academic All-America consideration, a student-athlete must first earn first-team All-District honors following a vote of the CoSIDA members in each district.
To qualify for nomination to the all-district ballot, a student-athlete must have a cumulative GPA of 3.30 or better, have attended the school at least two terms, be at least a sophomore in athletic eligibility and be a starter or key reserve in their respective sport.
Nebraska Wesleyan University CoSIDA Academic All-Americans
| Baseball | |
| Jay Lenstrom |
1980 |
| Phil Gaines |
1985, 1986 |
| Dan Routh |
1990, 1992 |
| Matt Kechely* |
1994, 1995 |
| Luke Klinker |
2002, 2003 |
*Academic All-American of the Year in 1995
| Football | |
| Jim Johnson |
1984 |
| John Hansen |
1987 |
| Pat Sweeney |
1987, 1988 |
| Michael Surls |
1988 |
| Steve Taylor |
1989 |
| Scott Shaffer |
1989 |
| Scott Shipman |
1989, 1990 |
| Curtis Fox |
1991 |
| Jay Bubak |
1992 |
| Jeff Wall |
1993 |
| Justin Rice |
1994, 1995, 1996 |
| Joe Mick |
1995 |
| Chad Wemhoff |
1995, 1996, 1997 |
| Ryan Shanesy |
1996, 1997, 1998 |
| Dusten Olds |
1997 |
| Justin Buresh |
2001 |
| Grant Leach |
2001 |
| Luke Klinker |
2001, 2002 |
| Cody Hoegh |
2005 |
| Scott Keller |
2005 |
| Kyle Elsasser |
2006, 2007 |
| Zach Egger |
2009 |
| Steven Anderson |
2011 |
| Garek Bebee |
2011 |
| Matt Edwards |
2011 |
| Cody Eiler |
2011 |
| Brett Kaczor |
2011 |
| Kelby Vandenberg |
2011 |
| Russell Walton |
2011 |
| Men's Basketball | |
| Kevin Cook |
1984, 1986 |
| Curtis Reimer |
1988 |
| Charles Burt |
1989 |
| Justin Wilkins |
1994, 1995 |
| Kipp Kissinger |
1996, 1997, 1998 |
| Andy Schwetizer |
2012 |
| Men's Golf | |
| Kelly Karmazin |
1996, 1997 |
| Men's Soccer | |
| Jon Buhrman |
2000 |
| Trevor Svoboda |
2001, 2002 |
| Mitchel Memming |
2005, 2007 |
| Men's Tennis | |
| Bryan Danforth |
2002 |
| Nate Anderson |
2008 |
| Men's Track & Field/ | Cross Country |
| Gary Wasserman |
1992, 1993 |
| Chad Wemhoff |
1998 |
| Brian Hauff |
2000 |
| Chris Isaacson |
2000, 2001 |
| Lee Seberger |
2003 |
| Gordie Coffin |
2005, 2006, 2007 |
| Jed Droge |
2006, 2007 |
| Evan Knight |
2006, 2007, 2008 |
| Derek Carson |
2008, 2009 |
| Brian Copley |
2010 |
| Kevin Janata |
2011 |
| Softball | |
| Diane Humphrey |
1987, 1988, 1989 |
| Kim McKay |
1991, 1992 |
| Traci Quick |
1994, 1995 |
| Lynne Fischer |
1996
|
| Marcia Kennedy |
2011
|
| Volleyball | |
| Kim Koelling |
1996,1997 |
| Women's Basketball | |
| Kim Hissong |
1986 |
| Malaine Tejkl |
1988 |
| Shea Rasmussen |
2012 |
| Women's Soccer | |
| Sandy Shaneyfelt |
1995, 1996 |
| Megan Littrell |
1999 |
| Laura Huppert |
2000 |
| Sarah Keller |
2000 |
| Sara Kunneman |
2001, 2002 |
| Jane Hoops |
2003 |
| Women's Tennis | |
| Leslie Barnes |
1996 |
| Jonna Kellenbarger |
1996 |
| Jennifer Olsen |
1997 |
| Women's Track & Field/ | Cross Country |
| Jessica Petersen |
2000 |
| Kelly Bowen |
2002 |
| Katie McGinnis |
2003 |
| Gina Morgan |
2004 |
| Erin Powell* |
2005, 2006 |
| Holly Andrews |
2008 |
* Academic All-American of the Year in 2006